mr. speaker , i heard an earlier speaker refer to class actions as a game .
try telling that to the 9-year-old son of janet huggins , a 39-year-old healthy tennessee mother who took vioxx and died in september 2004 .
tell her family that the effort to protect her family is a game .
this is not a game .
this is flesh and blood , the ability to protect your family when something happens to you that you did not have anything to do with .
this bill is the vioxx protection bill .
it is the wal-mart protection bill .
it is the tyco protection bill .
it is the enron protection bill .
anyone in the state of washington who saw what enron did to us , stealing $ 1 billion , should not be voting for this bill , because this bill in many ways is the just say no bill to people who are injured by rapacious wrongdoers .
in three ways it says `` just say no '' to consumers who were hurt by enron , because in the federal courts , if you happen to be in a plaintiff 's group of multiple states and the laws are a little different in the states , do you know what the federal courts do ?
they throw out the class action .
do you want to know why the chamber of commerce is spending $ 1 billion to lobby on what seems to be a procedural issue ?
because they throw out class actions where there is any difference in states , meaning you will not be able to have a class action anywhere , anywhere , federal or state .
why is this so important ?
i liken this to right now you have two arms to protect americans , the state judicial system and the federal judicial system .
this reduces by half the resources that are available to americans to get redress when enron steals from them or when vioxx kills them .
on 9/11 , did we respond to september 11 by taking out city police officers and only having the fbi ?
on 9/11 , did we respond by not having local fire departments and only having the coast guard or army fire department ?
no .
we recognized that in our system of federalism , americans deserve the full protection , not just half the protection .
this cuts the available judicial resources in half .
why is that important ?
the second reason it just says no to injured americans is the federal courts can not handle these class actions .
they do not have enough courts and judges .
you go down and ask how long you will wait today to get into a federal court .
then add about 4 or 5 years after this bill if this bill were to come into effect .
you just say no because it takes the keys away from the courthouse .
the third reason it just says no to good american citizens is it takes from the state attorneys general their ability to protect people .
that is why the states attorneys general , republican and democrat alike , are adamantly opposed to this bill , because this bill takes cops off the beat ; attorneys generals whose job it is to protect us from what roosevelt called the `` malefactors of great wealth '' are off the beat .
mr. speaker , we should reject this bill .

